How to Sell Inherited Jewelry in the Atlanta Area

TL;DR: Don’t scrap inherited jewelry blindly. Get it assessed for both melt value and any designer, gemstone, or antique premium, gather any papers, and work with a transparent local buyer who explains the offer.

Selling inherited jewelry can feel daunting — emotionally and practically. Here's how to do it confidently and get a fair price in the Atlanta area.

1. Don't rush to "scrap" it

Older and inherited pieces can carry value well beyond their metal weight — designer signatures, gemstones, craftsmanship, or antique/period interest. A piece worth more as jewelry than as scrap should be valued that way, and a good buyer will tell you which applies.

2. Gather anything that came with it

Boxes, receipts, appraisals, and grading reports all help establish value. Even without them, a qualified appraiser can assess the piece in person.

3. Understand melt value vs. market value

Melt value is the worth of the raw precious metal by weight and purity. Market value can be higher for pieces with diamonds, designer provenance, or collectibility. You should always be offered the higher of the two.

4. Choose a transparent, local buyer

Work with an established local shop that examines the piece in front of you, explains the offer, and lets you take your time. Offers should be no-obligation and good for several days.

Not ready to sell everything? You can also take a loan against a piece and keep the option to reclaim it. We also buy inherited coins and luxury goods if your inheritance includes more than jewelry.

Have questions or want a free, no-obligation quote? Contact us or call 678-264-8899 — walk-ins are always welcome at our Roswell store.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need an appraisal before bringing inherited jewelry in?
No. We have a free evaluation process where we assess the piece in person at no cost and explain how we arrived at the offer. Any existing appraisals or grading reports are helpful but not required.
Is old or broken jewelry still worth selling?
Yes! Even broken pieces carry value for their gold, silver, platinum, or gemstones, and older pieces may have designer or antique value beyond their metal content in some cases.
© 2026 Roswell Silver Dollar. All rights reserved.